2011-07-29 / Columnists

It’s My Turn

Sanitized History Is Boring History
Commentary By Stephen Preskill Chair, Education Department, Wagner College

Stephen Preskill is the chairman of the Education Department at Wagner College on Staten Island, N.Y., a U.S. News & World Report Top 25 regional university.

Last week the National Assessment of Education Progress, often referred to as the gold standard of standardized tests, indicated that American students at all levels are alarmingly ignorant of the most basic facts of our own history.

Only 20 percent of fourth-graders, and a shockingly low 12 percent of high school seniors, showed proficiency on the history exam. Most fourth-graders could not explain why Abraham Lincoln was significant. And only a tiny percentage of students could identify what Brown v. Board of Education, the landmark Supreme Court case, was about.

The conclusion is inescapable that the vast majority of students possess virtually no knowledge of history.

As a longtime educator and follower of educational trends, I am not at all surprised by these results. There has never been a time when American high school students have done well on history examinations. And, according to surveys conducted periodically since 1943 by the New York Times, there is every reason to believe that the level of historical knowledge among Americans of all age groups, not just school-aged children, is abysmal.

I believe that James Loewen, author of “Lies My Teacher Told Me,” has the most plausible answer for why we don’t know our own history: History is not retained or understood because it’s almost always taught in a boring way — and the reason it’s boring has everything to do with the half-truths and outright lies we tell about it.

Is it really not surprising that students don’t know about the Brown case when so many teachers provide them with so little historical context for understanding what a dramatic step forward that case represented? Why should our students know who Lincoln was when we so frequently withhold from them what a wily politician he was, or how far he progressed in his understanding of slavery and race during the course of the Civil War?

Unlike a good movie about real life that is often interesting because all the boring parts have been taken out, we tend to teach history in high school with all the boring parts left in and all the really fascinating material removed so as to not to offend anyone.

This has been true for decades. Our history textbooks bored students to death for most of the 20th century because everything controversial about American life — including racism, sexism, cultural genocide and overwhelming social and economic inequities — has been omitted.

If we ever find the courage to tell the true and often tragic story of American history, our students will sit up, take notice and learn. In the meantime, don’t expect change any time soon. Social studies is famous for being the most boring subject in school, and so it will remain as long as its textbooks and its teachers are unable to face up to the gut-wrenching but arresting truths about our history.

Return to top

One of the stories that my

One of the stories that my teacher I was taught about Abraham Lincoln was that he was a good horse trader. One day another horse trader made a bet with him that he could make a better bargain than old Honest Abe. They both agreed to bring their worst horses and make a trade of them and see who got the best trade. The next day the horse trader shows up with the ugliest, swayed back, flea infested horse the entire town had ever seen. A little while later Abe shows up with a wooden saw horse. Honest Abe looked at the horse trader and said "this is the first time I ever be bested in a horse trade" It is stories like these that my teachers would interject while speaking of Honest Abe. The two minute respite from the droning on of (he was born in, he died in yada, yada, yada,) a story that while maybe not factually true taught us to see something in a different light. Abe was a horse trader (fact). He may or may not have performed this actual trade but our teachers knew how to grab our imaginations and make learning fun and interesting. I thank all my teachers from PS.42, Mr. Podair, PS 225, Mrs. Silverman, Mrs. Schapp, JHS 198, Mr. Bienculli Mr. Deedee (did not have his class but played handball with him at lunch and learned more about social studies on that court than any other place.) REAL teachers teach life (whether old or new) and open our minds to explore. These are the teachers from whom new teachers should be forced to look at to learn what it takes to be a REAL teacher, from whom the BoE should look at and emulate. The people who took the time to reach out and who give a little more than a textbook and a forty minute class. “We who are about to live salute you.” (made it slightly different from actual quote) If you do not understand the last line then you did not have one of those types of teachers. Thank you all for making me a successful person in business and life itself.


Email Us
Contact Us

Copyright 1999 - 2014 Wave Publishing Co. All Rights Reserved

Neighborhoods | History